Unlock the Editor’s Digest totally free
Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly publication.
Simply days into his presidency, Indonesia’s new chief has despatched a robust message to overseas tech corporations seeking to promote on the planet’s fourth-most populous nation: make investments regionally or lose entry to the market.
However analysts warned that technique, which remade Indonesia’s economic system as a commodities powerhouse, might backfire in opposition to the likes of Apple and Google as competitors within the area for overseas direct funding heats up.
Over the previous week, Prabowo Subianto’s authorities has banned gross sales of Apple’s iPhone 16 and Google’s Pixel telephones, citing the businesses’ failure to satisfy necessities for 40 per cent of merchandise to be made with regionally sourced uncooked supplies.
“We’re encouraging the local content policy to create fairness for all investors, as well as to create added value domestically,” mentioned Febri Hendri Antoni Arief, a spokesperson for the trade ministry, on Friday.
The bans, which got here every week after Prabowo was inaugurated, sign that south-east Asia’s largest economic system might step up using restrictive commerce insurance policies to safe investments from overseas corporations.
Critics mentioned such insurance policies might dent Indonesia’s attraction — which is hampered by purple tape and corruption — in opposition to extra investment-friendly nations within the area comparable to Vietnam and Malaysia. The restrictions additionally come as Prabowo has set out bold plans to spice up annual financial development to eight per cent.
“Indonesia takes a hit in its competitiveness compared to other countries in south-east Asia as a result of this kind of policy,” mentioned Lydia Ruddy, managing director of the American Chamber of Commerce in Indonesia.
Ruddy mentioned it might be “very challenging” for overseas corporations to satisfy native content material thresholds as a result of domestically made merchandise weren’t out there for some sectors comparable to electronics, prescribed drugs, medical gadgets and renewable power.
“This becomes a real deterrent for foreign investors. If they cannot import the products or materials they need and they are not available on the local market yet, companies will look to other markets in the region,” she mentioned.
Indonesia has lengthy used commerce laws to draw overseas funding and onshore manufacturing to guard its home industries. The native content material requirement is certainly one of its strongest mechanisms, requiring industries from power to agriculture equipment to regionally supply a sure proportion of products. For energy vegetation, it’s as excessive as 70 per cent.
This yr, Indonesia relaxed the native content material requirement for solar energy plant initiatives in a bid to facilitate overseas funding. The power minister on the time, Arifin Tasrif, mentioned the requirement had made initiatives rather more costly for overseas corporations.
Indonesia’s protectionism has been much more aggressive in commodities. Prabowo’s predecessor Joko Widodo banned nickel ore exports in 2019, forcing overseas corporations to spend money on home nickel processing amenities. The coverage drew file funding within the metal and electrical car sectors, each of which use nickel extensively.
Whereas Prabowo has mentioned he will likely be investment-friendly, he’s but to set out detailed plans. He has vowed to proceed Widodo’s coverage of “downstreaming”, or including worth to commodities, to spice up the worth of the nation’s exports.
On the Qatar Financial Discussion board in Might, Prabowo pushed again in opposition to criticism of Indonesia’s “downstreaming” insurance policies. “We are not protectionist,” he mentioned. “What we are doing is very logical. Every country in the world will fight or protect the national interests of its people.”
His authorities’s latest strikes point out a concentrate on expertise corporations. Within the closing weeks of the Widodo administration, officers mentioned they might ban Chinese language ecommerce platforms Temu and Shein due to the potential hurt to small- and medium-sized enterprises from cheaper overseas merchandise.
Prabowo’s administration has not commented on the bans on Temu and Shein.
Indonesia holds nice potential for corporations comparable to Apple and Google attributable to its younger, tech-savvy inhabitants. The variety of energetic cellphones in Indonesia totals 354mn, in accordance with the nation’s trade ministry, exceeding the inhabitants of 280mn.
Indonesia has beforehand known as for extra funding from Apple, which has 4 developer academies within the nation to coach college students and engineers to develop apps however no manufacturing facility.
The Widodo administration had requested Apple to arrange a manufacturing facility or analysis and improvement centre, saying the developer academies weren’t sufficient, however Apple’s chief govt Tim Prepare dinner, who met Widodo in Jakarta this yr, didn’t make any commitments.
The ban on Apple and Google is an try by Indonesia to have extra bargaining energy, however it’s a powerful promote as a result of “Indonesia still lacks the manufacturing capabilities”, mentioned Bhima Yudhistira, director of the Heart of Financial and Legislation Research in Jakarta.
“This is a bad precedent for investors and potential partners for Indonesia under the Prabowo administration,” he mentioned. “The government has failed to increase the fundamental competitiveness to attract more investments.”
